On dying for your country

The movie Patton (1970) begins with a monologue by General Patton which is composed of statements he made at various times in speeches and letters. The movie makers combined these statements into a single speech to introduce the character of the general to the movie audience. One of Patton’s statements included in the monologue is, “I want you to remember that no [soldier] ever won a war by dying for his country. They won by making the other poor dumb [soldier] die for his country.”

President Trump appears to agree with General Patton regarding which soldiers are most successful. In fact, I strongly suspect that the President once quoted that line from the movie in the presence of some person or persons who misunderstood the context of the quote and exaggerated its impact when they repeated the line to a reporter. People who know the President insist that he did not make such a statement under the circumstances that have been reported. Even if, at some time, President Trump did speak those words that came from General Patton, such a statement would not have been meant as an insult to American soldiers who fought for their country and lost their lives on the battlefield.

Ideally, the armed forces of the United States should be so powerful and so respected that they do not have to fight. No other country would dare challenge our nation militarily. As President Theodore Roosevelt said, we should “speak softly and carry a big stick.” For that purpose, the United States trains and equips the members of our Army, Navy, Air Force, and Coast Guard so they can do their best, not only in wartime conditions but also in every other task that is required of them. Nevertheless, they risk their lives by doing their duty. We thank them, honor and respect them for their service to the country, and support them as well as we can both while they are in uniform and when they are veterans. We also honor those who lost their lives. We wish they had not died, but we honor and respect them and are grateful for their sacrifice.

President Trump frequently says things that jar the sensibilities of his audience. He did so long before entering politics; this tendency is part of the image he created and marketed, and his supporters expect him to continue speaking this way. When he quotes movies, his witnesses should at least have the presence of mind to know the origin and context of the quote. Failing that basic knowledge, they do not need to be telling reporters what the President said and what he meant when he said it. J.

4 thoughts on “On dying for your country

  1. Thanks, Jay, for the clarification. I trust President Trump and I know he respects the military so I was in a bit of quandary about what might have happened. I did question the motivation of the report largely because of the timing. It is hard to not question motives of people who remember something just at the most convenient time to affect an election. You are so right about our needing to have a military that is strong enough to prevent our people from being killed. No war, no killing.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Misunderstanding a person’s true intent, especially in moral issues, convictions, and sincere sentiment are usually the result of knee-jerk, whirlwind judgments. Sadly, such is all too common undisciplined human nature. Not to insinuate that either Patton or Trump are without character flaws, they both are subject to extreme scrutiny from their critics. The same acute misconceptions condemned Christ.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I can remember my dad taking mom, my brother and me to a drive-in to see Patton
    I think mother regretted the movie choice given the language of the monologue but I was hooked— it played right to my fascination with all things WWII— I hate he slapped that soldier – a terrible mark on a great leader— but not all great military leaders, or political leaders for that matter, are free of blemishes or faults or mistakes— so we all well know— but some just wear those blemishes a bit more unabashedly and perhaps I can respect them the better for that

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s